In an MIT briefing on The Impact of COVID-19 on Business and Supply Chain last week, professor Yossi Sheffi recommended that one of the actions companies should start taking right now is “plan for the recovery.” I agree with the need to start thinking longer-term now, but is it really as simple as recovery? Someday, hopefully soon, the crisis will be “over” and the world will return to normal?
While supply can recover as factories come back online and transportation routes are reinstated, I believe demand will be different. The Coronavirus crisis will have both immediate and long-lasting effects on consumer demand, from what they buy, to how much they buy and how they buy it. As a result, traditional demand signals, like customer orders, will no longer be reliable business indicators as retailers and other trading partners struggle to catch up to the new normal, and the past is no longer a good predictor of the future.
Take hand soap as an example. Consumers will logically continue to consume more soap as they continue to wash their hands more often, so demand will go up compared to before. A less straightforward example is breakfast foods. Will consumers buy more cereal or pancake mix now than before, as they develop a habit of eating breakfast at home during this period, and if so, what will that do to demand for on-the-go breakfast bars in the future? Also, will they continue to head to the store to stock up, or having tried grocery delivery, will they stick with the newfound convenience?
One of Alloy’s customers, a consumer electronics executive, recently shared with me that he also believes consumer behavior is going to change much faster than anybody thought, and change for good. For example, Best Buy stores are now all closed and shopping has quickly shifted online. Even when stores reopen though, he questions whether consumers will return in the same numbers to experience and purchase products. Touching the same demo product everyone else has and standing in line to check out can suddenly seem unsafe and unnecessary after experiencing an alternative.
The research backs him up too: In February 2014, a three-day strike on the London Tube forced commuters to experiment with new routes. Afterward, around one in 20 stuck with their new commutes—and that’s a very small change compared to what we are experiencing today!
A framework for uncertain times
In the short, medium, and long-term, the size and shape of demand will continue to evolve. To be ready to respond, consumer goods manufacturers need to get closer than ever to the end consumer: identify shifts as soon as they start to happen, and break them down by product, channel, and partner to pinpoint how the business is affected and determine the right course of action.
In this post, we lay out a framework to help you quickly spot when demand for each of your products is rising, falling, or re-distributing. Then by de-averaging the impact, sales and supply chain teams can act swiftly to optimize supply and partner effectively with retailers.
The framework doesn’t require waiting for retailers to make the first move—a risky proposition that could mean being too late to respond to demand shifts, mis-allocating inventory, or even moving in the wrong direction as retailers can over- or under- react to fluctuations and anomalies. It takes into account three different definitions of “demand”:
- What retailers expect consumers to buy, which is reflected in orders (commonly referred to as sell-in)
- What consumers actually buy, which is reflected in store point-of-sale and e-commerce sales data (commonly referred to as sell-through or sell-out)
- What consumers would like to buy, whether they are able to do so or not, which must be derived based on sell-through and some measure of lost sales (commonly referred to as true demand or unconstrained demand)
When consumer demand is stable, these three demand metrics are all about the same in an efficiently operating supply chain (seasonality aside). Consumers are able to actually buy just about everything they want (unconstrained demand ≈ sell-through), and retailers are ordering from manufacturers just about enough to meet that demand (sell-through ≈ sell-in). That may still be the case for certain categories that are not really affected by the pandemic, though I struggle to imagine any.
How is your demand changing?
More telling is when you can see differences between these three metrics. Their relative relationship can tell you whether the business is rising, falling, or redistributing, and help you take the right actions the first time.
Rising consumer demand
If consumers would like to buy more than they are able to based on what retailers are ordering (unconstrained demand > sell-in), the news is mostly good: in the current situation, this product is more desired by consumers than before. Your top priority is to figure out how to best allocate supply, and look out for long-term growth patterns that might justify broader shifts in production.
Falling consumer demand
Conversely, if orders are out-pacing what consumers are buying or would like to buy (sell-in > unconstrained demand), it means consumers are shifting away from your product at the moment. Demand is likely dropping, and you need to reflect that information back up through your production and to your suppliers, as well as monitor your current inventory levels.
Redistributing consumer demand
When retailers are ordering what consumers would like to buy (sell-in ≈ unconstrained demand), but surprisingly, what consumers actually manage to buy (sell-through) is lower, an underlying shift is happening. It’s the old cliché in action, “the right product, in the right places, at the right time.” In this case, your products are not in the right places for consumers to be able to buy them.
So far, this scenario has been the most common impact on demand that we’ve seen from COVID-19. Across our customers, whether they’re in CPG, consumer electronics, automotive, or toys, we keep seeing a similar situation play out: a retailer has a sizable drop in point-of-sale (POS), say 20%, and may even cut orders because, in aggregate, there is plenty of inventory left. However, warehouses used to fill online orders are running dangerously low because most sales have shifted to e-commerce. Looking at total inventory doesn’t help when it’s all stuck in closed stores.
In this case, consider asking for additional e-commerce orders, or even for reverse logistics if it’s a feasible way to rebalance inventory. Examine each of your partners and look at how they are adjusting to the demand redistribution. If needed, consider offering up a form of collaborative planning, forecasting, and replenishment (CPFR) to help ensure the right products are getting to the right places.
When applying this framework, breaking things down to a granular level is key. What’s happening will likely not be the same for each of your products, partners and channels, so high-level averages can be misleading or hide useful insights. BCG’s Consumer Spend Pulse has been monitoring sales growth in key categories in recent weeks vs. pre-crisis, and shows not only a difference by category, but also by metro areas, offline vs. online segments, and brand—making it critical to “de-average the impact.”
At a minimum, you should always be de-averaging your demand along three dimensions:
- Product category, e.g., laundry vs. dish cleaner
- Sales channel, primarily e-commerce vs. brick & mortar
- Partner, primarily individual retailers
Additional dimensions that may be useful for your business include:
- Partner category, e.g., mass retail vs. specialty retail
- Fulfillment channel, e.g., Buy Online Pickup In Store (BOPIS) vs. doorstep delivery
- Geography, e.g., areas with “stay at home” orders vs. those without
This detailed analysis has helped some of our customers gain insight into how demand is moving in different directions for different parts of their business, and where they need to focus their efforts. For example, if demand for your home office products category is rising but demand for school supplies is falling, devote more resources to the former while keeping an eye out for rising Weeks of Supply in the latter. Or if most sales are happening online, focus on ensuring adequate inventory levels at the warehouses they’re fulfilled from instead of store in-stock levels.
Ensure continuous visibility
From crisis response to the new normal, a current and precise picture of consumer demand is one of the most valuable tools you can have. Because if you think your demand hasn’t started to shift yet, maybe it’s because you’re waiting for orders to reflect it. Or maybe it truly hasn’t, but don’t you want to know the moment it does?
This imperative isn’t just for Sales either. Now more than ever, Supply Chain teams also have to be close to the end-consumer. If we can put a positive spin on the COVID-19 pandemic, perhaps it can be the light it has shown on supply chains and how much we rely on them to function efficiently.
So ensure teams throughout your organization have easy access to sell-through data—made available on a daily basis, and broken down by at least category, channel, and partner to support de-averaging analysis. Most retailers already share point-of-sale in some form or another, and there have even been calls for additional retail data sharing to help suppliers during this critical time. Traditional feedback mechanisms, while familiar, are just too slow, and maybe even incorrect, to run a business amid changing demand.
To help you navigate this uncertain time, Alloy is offering an out-of-the-box deployment for all your data at a select retailer - complimentary for one month. Learn more and sign up here!